GTA VI: How Our Contradictions Confuse Our Children
This was the response I received from a 13-year-old student when I asked why he had pre-ordered GTA VI.

“Everyone else is getting it.”
This was the response I received from a 13-year-old student when I asked why he had pre-ordered GTA VI. I know the series from my own youth, when I played it with friends around twenty years ago. It wasn’t okay then, and it is certainly not okay now.
I don’t intend to lecture anyone sat on my high horse. But as parents, our responsibility is to learn from our own mistakes. The conversation I had with my class of teenagers could take place in many homes. We ask what the game is about, our child tells us about the cars, and soon we begin to doubt ourselves. Are we being too strict? They just want to join in with their friends. Saying yes is easier, and it might even appear reasonable. That does not make it right.
In all honesty, this is not even a “strict Muslim parent” issue. The game’s UK listing carries an eighteen rating and warnings for sex, drugs and extreme violence. Rockstar’s listing includes nudity, strong sexual content, strong language, and drug and alcohol use. The warnings are there before we buy it. It’s then our job to take heed.
Just think about that. Even in a society that accepts so much sexual content and violence as entertainment, there is a recognition that children should be protected from certain material. If a rating system that does not account for our religious concerns already considers this unsuitable for children, what are we relying on when we decide otherwise?
“He only drives the cars” leaves everything around the cars unanswered. If driving is the attraction, consider a racing game such as F1 25 or Gran Turismo 7, checking the content, music and online settings first. How can we justify everything else in GTA for the sake of driving a car?
The question extends to us as adults. We do not outgrow the instruction to lower our gaze or the need to avoid music. I struggle to see how we reconcile our deen with choosing entertainment that includes this content. We may not be buying the game for those scenes, but we still have to consider what we are willing to overlook. Fictional characters do not remove our responsibility for what we choose to watch or play.
We want our children to have haya, to speak well, to respect others and to feel that the deen has a core place in their lives beyond our madrasas and Islamic schools.
And therein lies the contradiction. We want to protect our children from these things, yet we pay to bring those same things into their lives. We expect them to understand what is wrong while our own money and permission tell them it is acceptable. How confusing must that be for a child?
I want our children to enjoy their childhood, and there is room within our deen for play, friendship and relaxation. Saying no to this game can still be a kind conversation, but we should give some thought to what follows it. Are we willing to organise something with their friends, take them out or spend an evening doing something they enjoy? That requires more from us than buying a potentially destructive video game. If we are always too occupied to spend time with our children, we should reflect on how much support we give them to find the enjoyment we consider suitable.
The practical steps matter too: check what is installed, use age restrictions and purchase approvals, and make sure relatives and older siblings understand the same boundary. Owning the game is not the only way to be exposed to its content, especially if others close to us have the game.
And if we are playing it ourselves, we should be prepared for our children to ask why. “Because I’m older” does not answer the question. Turning eighteen does not make prohibited content permissible.
This is where, as an imam, I find the conversation challenging. We allow the content, make allowances for the language, and then, when we become worried about our child, we ask the ulama to pick up the pieces. “Maulana, please speak to him. He doesn’t listen to us.”
Of course we should ask for help. I want parents to feel they can approach their imam, including when they regret a decision. But we can’t be blind to our own obligations: what we are willing to change at home.
What is the imam supposed to achieve if he speaks about modesty and the child returns to the same content with the same parental approval? We ask him to explain why something matters, while our choices suggest it does not matter very much. Then we wonder why his words have not made a difference.
We cannot keep removing the boundaries at home and expect our masjids, madrasas and Islamic schools to put them back every afternoon.
The Prophet ﷺ said:
كُلُّكُمْ رَاعٍ، وَكُلُّكُمْ مَسْئُولٌ عَنْ رَعِيَّتِهِ
“Each of you is a guardian, and each of you is responsible for those in your care.”
(Sahih al-Bukhari 7138)
Good parents can have children who struggle. No parent controls every influence, and I include myself in that. But we do control what we buy and what we continue to permit once we understand it.
Before we ask the Imam to speak to our children, we should ask whether we are willing to act on the advice ourselves. He is not a miracle worker. His advice needs to be supported by the decisions we make at home. If we want our children to take these boundaries seriously, they need to see that we take them seriously too.
When we have unity in our messaging, our boundaries and our actions, we will inshaAllah see the changes we all intend for our children.
